With 71 minutes on the clock in the Cake Tin in Wellington, Scotland 3 metres from the Puma’s line ref Wayne Barnes puts his arm out to signal penalty advantage to the Scots.
At that moment the decision making by Mike Blair and Dan Parkes cost a home nation (probably Scotland) a knock out place in the world cup.
Scotland were in possession and going forward had they not have scored the try then Wayne Barnes would have brought them back for the penalty. If the Scots’ half backs had have been positive then one of two things would have happened.
- Scotland would have scored a try taking them either 8 points or 10 points clear after the conversion there would have been only 6 or 7 minutes left to play meaning Scotland would probably have won.
- Scotland would have gone through phases and not scored, Wayne Barnes would have brought Scotland back for the easy penalty. The Scots would have had more time to compose themselves for the next kick off & may well have not conceded the try.
This is a common fault in rugby, any young half backs out there if 5 metres out close to the posts be positive, if you don’t score a try you will still get the chance of three points.
Sure Scotland can try to blame Wayne Barnes, he should have give penalty against Contepomi in the last play & his management of the contact area was debatable.
But as coaches and players we are not able to control the referee but we can control our own decision making. If you ask Blair or Parkes now they will say they got it wrong.
Now barring a Georgian miracle either Scotland or England are going home. Scotland need to win the clash with England; scoring 4 tries in the process and stopping England getting the losing bonus point.
All eyes now on Eden Park Auckland will it be Argentina, England or Scotland on the plane home. Anything is possible but it looks like the Scots exiting at the group stages for the first time.
I for one hope not, for the sake of home nations rugby I will be hoping for a Georgian win next Sunday in Palmerston North.
Donny









